Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Monday, December 11, 2006

More on open data

Rebeca Cliffe, Research Data: Emerging From The Shadows?  EPS Insights, December 11, 2006 (accessible only to subscribers).  Excerpt:

The journal article continues to be the key mechanism for communicating research findings, but in an online context, where space is not an issue, it becomes possible to publish the raw data on which those findings were based. At the RIN workshop, research funders and practitioners discussed current initiatives and how best to exploit opportunities for making more raw data available online....Centre, data is increasingly important as evidence. "Experimental verifiability is the basis of science, and if the journal article is the only evidence we have it is less verifiable than if we also have the raw data"....

One of the key challenges is to persuade researchers to deposit data systematically, something that Juan Bicarregui, e-Science department, CCLRC, pointed out "will require a huge cultural change; education will be key". In a sentiment echoed by a number of speakers, David Shotton argued that "we need to create tools to make it easy for researchers to create metadata as part of their workflow. Even then, it will still require effort, so we must make it clearly advantageous for researchers to do so". Peter Dukes, Research Management Group, Medical Research Council, spoke of the "absence of a grassroots movement for data sharing" and researchers' concerns about possible loss of control over their data and the implications for their reputation.

In discussion, it became clear that while there are common challenges and opportunities across the scholarly community, there are also differences in how the question can be addressed across the different disciplines....

Another goal cited by Bicarregui and others was that the future e-infrastructure should support the use for research purposes of data collected for other purposes....