Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Friday, June 09, 2006

Coalition of society publishers opposes FRPAA

The DC Principles Coalition has released its June 7 letter to to Senators Cornyn and Lieberman, opposing the FRPAA. The society publishers in the coalition oppose the OA mandate, want to lengthen the six month embargo, assert that the bill will harm them, and nevertheless assert that it duplicates much of what they already do.

Comments. Three quick comments:

  1. I've responded to all these arguments already, e.g. in my comments on the AAP.
  2. "Scientific societies fully support the goal of increasing access to research..." This is true except for the word "fully". As their letter shows, these societies compromise their support for the goal of increasing access to research in order to support their revenue streams.
  3. I repeat my assessment that "publishers who object to [national OA policies] are defending the remarkable proposition that they should control access to research conducted by others, written up by others, and funded by taxpayers." They are putting their interests as publishers ahead of their interests as scientific societies.