Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Wednesday, June 21, 2006

ACS editorial against FRPAA backfires

Alexander Scheeline, a professor of chemistry at the University of Illinois, has released his June 7 letter to Senator Susan Collins in support of FRPAA. (Thanks to Katie Newman.) Excerpt:
You doubtless will get many responses to an editorial by Rudy M. Baum, editor of the American Chemical Society's Chemical and Engineering News, opposing S.2695 [FRPAA]. While I will not comment on legislative specifics, I do believe that something like S.2695 is in the public interest, that the fears of publishers are only valid to the extent that they are defending turf, prerogatives, and a pre-internet view of the world, and that a Federal push for openness could help scholarly communications significantly....

For the taxpayers to be able to see what they've paid for is commendable. The technical means to ensure this happens are rapidly evolving, so any technical "lock-in" at this point is premature. I thus encourage you to keep the publishers scared to encourage them to keep cutting costs and (one hopes) capping subscription expense, while encouraging inventive ways to publish quality material. The threat of S.2695 may be more useful than passing the bill.

PS: Kudos to Prof. Scheeline. I hope this means that society publishers who try to rouse their members against FRPAA will rouse at least as many in support of it. To write your own message to Senator Colllins (chair of the Senate committee considering FRPAA), send it to

The Honorable Susan Collins
United States Senate
461 Dirksen Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20510-1904