Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Tuesday, November 29, 2005

Another blog posting on the Royal Society statement

Stuart Yeates, Royal Society has come out against Open Access Journals? November 28, 2005. Excerpt:
I'm personally not convinced that this story represents the considered opinion of the Royal Society as a whole. The issue is challenging for the Royal Society, because like many scholarly societies they currently derive a large portion of their income from selling journals to institutional libraries. On the other hand, open access can provide faster, cheaper and more transparent submission, peer review, publication and dissemination than printed journals or closed electronic journals....[After quoting the Royal Society:] All their significant qualms appear to be about funding.

Stephen Downes quotes Yeates' comment in his own blog and adds this comment: "I'm sympathetic, though I caution, the purpose of academic publishing is not to keep organizations like the Royal Society afloat, much as they may feel otherwise."