Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Sunday, October 23, 2005

More on Publishers v. Google

Kevin Werbach, Breaking Apart at the Seams, Werblog, October 20, 2005. (Thanks to Rob Hof.) Excerpt:
The Net works because of a series of informal agreements...[Examples]...And websites allow search engines to copy their content into indexes, even though at some level that action raises copyright concerns. The Google Print lawsuit puts the last of these practices in question. On some level, copying a Web page to facilitate searching isn't all that different from copying a book to facilitate searching. And copying an RSS feed to put content onto another site isn't so different either. Unravel the notion that some content sharing benefits everyone, and therefore should be acceptable despite the nominal boundaries of intellectual property, and the Internet economy, especially the Web 2.0 economy, comes crashing down. What's worrisome to me is that, just as the informal practices for sharing online content are being challenged, the informal practices for sharing Internet traffic and addressing are under stress as well....Years from now, will we look back at this as the period when the Internet came apart at its seams?