Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Tuesday, June 15, 2004

Johns Hopkins allows postprint archiving, sometimes

Johns Hopkins University Press is revising its copyright policy to allow postprint archiving, with some confusing, arbitrary, and onerous restrictions. Clause 3 of the new policy gives permission in advance "to include the Article in your own personal or departmental database or on-line site". However, Clause 4 says that you may "include the Article in your institutional database provided the database does not directly compete with either the Johns Hopkins University Press or Project Muse, is non-commercial, is institution specific and not a repository that is disciplined based and/or accepts contributions from outside the institution" --and provided that you request permission in advance. (PS: Distinguishing a faculty member's web site on the institutional server from the faculty member's section within the institutional repository on the same server is already a tenuous and arbitrary distinction. This policy goes further and distinguishes the departmental repository from the overal institutional repository. Moreover, how will JH determine whether a given institutional repository "competes" with JHUP or Project Muse?)