Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Tuesday, May 18, 2004

Review of alternatives to OA

Robin Peek, The Free-Access Debate Flourishes, Information Today 21(5), 17-18 (May 2004). (Not available online.) Peek reviews three alternatives to open access offered up in recent months, including the Royal Society's statement to the U.K. inquiry, the DC Principles, and the ALPSP Principles. The former two advocate freeing the literature after a limited embargo, while the ALPSP advocates "mechanisms that support free or very inexpensive access to journals." However, Peek asks "How open is open enough? How free is free enough? How deep is the commitment to those countires who cannot afford the tolls? And in the final analysis, which position really will 'do it better'?"