Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Tuesday, March 02, 2004

Editorial supports Lofgren bill

What copy rights? An unsigned editorial in the March 2 Mercury News. Excerpt: "A record of 0-3 in the courts is not heartening; for copyright reformers, it's a signal to turn up the heat in Washington. If the courts won't uphold consumers' rights, then Congress, which created the problem by passing a bad copyright law, must. Three times in the past three years, federal courts have banned the distribution of technologies that let consumers make copies of the digital works that they own....In both cases, the judges upheld the law but provoked a bigger question: What can consumers do when copyright holders deny them basic rights, like making personal copies, that they have had in the non-digital world with videotapes, records and books? Apparently not much....Last year, U.S. Rep. Zoe Lofgren of San Jose introduced a bill that would explicitly allow purchasers of digital works to use them in the same ways that courts have said they could use videotapes and records. The latest court decision should prod Congress to get off the dime and pass it."