I downloaded the latest stable version of Moodle and upgraded HEDD. All seems to be working properly at this point.
Upgrade procedure:
ETA: The upgrade from 1.5.1 to 1.5.3+ does not seem to work properly for the wiki module. I grabbed the tarball I made in step 2 and made that the active version. The database now complains slightly about prior version numbers when entering admin mode, but the site works properly.
I upgraded milter-greylist from version 2.0b5 to 2.0.2 this morning. A new configure option, —with-libspf2_10 is required for the version of the SPF library we have. Installing requires changing the program name from milter-greylist to greylist, as the rc.d script I wrote for FreeBSD 5 uses the latter.