Open Access NewsNews from the open access movement Jump to navigation |
|||||||||||||||
More on whether gold OA support is premature Stevan Harnad, The Argument Against (Premature) Gold OA Support, Open Access Archivangelism, June 12, 2009. This is a relatively short excerpt from a long post. Those following the debate should read the whole thing. Excerpt:
Update (6/15/09). Also see (1) Stevan's discussion with David Prosser on this point, (2) his clarification on Michael Smith's blog, and (3) his new post arguing that "it is far more productive (of OA) for universities and funders to mandate Green OA than to fund Gold OA." Update (6/20/09). Also see Bill Hooker's comments on both Stevan Harnad's and Stuart Shieber's contributions in this debate. Counting on the next generation of researchers At a World Science Festival in New York yesterday, six high school students interviewed Harold Varmus.
The backfiles to the journal Études, 1856-2000, are now online via Gallica. See also a 19-page dossier prepared by the Bibliothèque nationale de France.
Bonnie Swoger, Scholarly Communication 101, The Undergraduate Science Librarian, June 5, 2009.
Presentations from Biblioteca Digital Colombiana conference
The presentations from Integración de contenidos digitales a través de redes académicas avanzadas (Bogotá, June 4-5, 2009) are now online.
More data on impact of unauthorized downloads on book sales Brian O'Leary, The impact of piracy, Magellan Media Partners, June 8, 2009. (Thanks to Boing Boing.)
See also the related slides. See also our past posts on O'Leary's research. Notes on French digitization event Lionel Maurel, Bibliothèques numériques et mentions légales : un aperçu des pratiques en France, :: S.I.Lex ::, June 5, 2009. Read it in the original French or Google's English. Notes on Numériser les œuvres du domaine public, et après ? Diffusion, réutilisation, exploitation : des objectifs contradictoires ? (Paris, June 4, 2009). DINI position paper on research data The DINI working group on electronic publishing has released a position paper on research data, Positionspapier Forschungsdaten (version 1.0, April 2009). (Thanks to Klaus Graf.) Update (6/13/09). Here's the report in Google's English.
The theme of the latest issue of AIDAinformazioni is Open Access in Italia. (Thanks to Fabrizio Tinti.) Each article has an English abstract.
Richard Poynder, The world’s first Open Access Mandate? Open and Shut? June 12, 2009. Excerpt:
Comments. Many thanks to Richard and Jens for digging this up. I'm very much interested in the prehistory of OA myself, especially Richard's question #3. Here are a couple of other early episodes from my files.
Update (6/29/09). Here's another early (1965) example. On July 28, 1965, the US Office of Education published the following policy statement in the Federal Register:
Thanks to Jonathan Miller for digging this up. For more detail, see his article, “Publishers did not take the bait”: A Forgotten Precursor to the NIH Public Access Policy, a preprint forthcoming in the Spring 2009 issue of College & Research Libraries. The US Office of Education was the predecessor to the current US Department of Education. The USOE approach --putting publicly-funded research into the public domain-- was tried again in June 2003 by Martin Sabo in the Public Access to Science Act. For more detail, and a critique of this approach, see my July 2003 article on the Sabo bill. New index of library-UP publishing partnerships
Columbia University Libraries/Information Services and SPARC have released a list of Campus-Based Publishing Partnerships, collaborations between libraries and university presses to support publishing. The index includes a list of OA journals.
Financial pressures nudge California toward open textbooks
Michael B. Farrell, Schwarzenegger's push for digital textbooks, Christian Science Monitor, June 11, 2009.
See also our past post on the California initiative. New tool for publishing online collections
Tom Scheinfeldt, Omeka 1.0 Drops Today, Omeka, June 2, 2009. (Thanks to Charles Bailey.)
OA support from the other AAUP Kate Maternowski, Who Profits From For-Profit Journals? Inside Higher Ed, June 12, 2009. Excerpt:
Comment. I welcome the support for OA journals. However, the discussion is oddly unbalanced. If we conceive the problem as alienated labor in the academy and working for for-profit corporations, then it's understandable that the solution will include systematic efforts to submit new work to journals from other kinds of publishers. But if we conceive the problem as access barriers to new research, when researchers did not write it for money and benefit from circulating it as widely as possible, then the solution will be peer-reviewed OA --with much less concern for the precise corporate or profit status of the provider. I encourage members of the AAUP to widen their vision to all forms of OA provider, including for-profit OA publishers like BioMed Central and Medknow, as well as to all forms of OA itself, including green OA (deposit in OA repositories), not just gold OA (submission to OA journals). Report recommends OA policy at Concordia U Kathleen Shearer, Open Access at Concordia University: A Report for the Office of Research, March 27, 2009. Excerpt:
Comment. This is an excellent set of recommendations, effectively packaged with a supporting argument and OA policies from other institutions. Here's hoping that the Concordia faculty and administration will read it with care. Audio proceedings of two recent events Sun has released the audio of two recent events, for playback or download:
More on the university-press statement in support of OA Barbara Fister, On the Same Page: Ten University Presses Support Open Access, Library Journal, June 11, 2009. This excerpt picks up after Barbara quotes the statement in support of OA from 10 North American university presses, and my comments on it:
Bob Grant, Editors quit after fake paper flap, The Scientist, June 11, 2009. Excerpt:
Comments
OASPA launches a blog, comments on the Bentham affair The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA) has launched a blog. In its inaugural post, yesterday, it points out several ways in which practices at Bentham Science appear to fall short of the association's code of conduct, and that Bentham is not a member of OASPA. Calculating the size of the public domain
Rufus Pollock, Estimating Information Production and the Size of the Public Domain, miscellaneous factZ, June 9, 2009.
See also our past post on Pollock's related work on automated identification of copyright status. Presentation on DRIVER project
Dale Peters, DRIVER: Building a sustainable repository infrastructure to support national and international scholarly communication, presented at Deutscher Bibliothekartag (Erfurt, Germany, June 2-5, 2009). Abstract:
This paper presents some of the challenges of the DRIVER II project, which aims to internationalise the DRIVER Information Space in three ways: in building an international DRIVER Community / Confederation; in growing Open Access content to address the challenge of innovative scholarly research and communications; and in the deployment and replication the robust e-Infrastructure and services developed by DRIVER. Institutional memberships at York U.
York University Libraries have institutional memberships for many journals, YFile, June 9, 2009.
... York University Libraries have institutional memberships for BioMed Central (BMC), publisher of 186 peer-reviewed open access journals, and Public Library of Science (PLoS) journals. The memberships cover author fees for publication in BMC journals and a 10-per-cent discount for PLoS submissions. ... IMLS grantees at Open Repositories
Institute of Museum and Library Services, IMLS Grants Highlighted at Open Repositories Conference, press release, June 8, 2009.
ROARMAP now covers ETD mandates too Stevan Harnad has circulated this announcement to several lists:
PS: I second the motion, and hope that every research institution will mandate OA for ETDs as well for the peer-reviewed research articles of the faculty. Berners-Lee to help open UK government data David Meyer, PM calls on Berners-Lee in open-government drive, ZDNet UK, June 10, 2009. Excerpt:
Alma Swan and Leslie Chan officially launched OASIS (Open Access Scholarly Information Sourcebook) at ELPUB 2009 (Milan, June 10-12, 2009). The OASIS subtitle or motto is:
From today's announcement:
Comments
Labels: Hot YouTube channel for Italian repository software PuMa, the Italian repository software, has launched a YouTube channel. The channel currently offers three videos:
Dorothea Salo, “Keeping copyright”, Caveat Lector, June 9, 2009.
Revues.org now hosts more than 200 journals
Seven more journals have been approved to join Revues.org, bringing the total number of journals on Revues.org over 200. As with all journals on Revues.org, the recently-joined journals will be OA or delayed OA.
Another society adds a Wellcome-compliant OA option
Robert Kiley, American Society of Hemtaology implements Wellcome-compliant author pays option, UK PubMed Central Blog, June 10, 2009.
New OA index on European history European History Primary Sources is a new OA index of "scholarly websites that offer on-line access to primary sources on the history of Europe", sponsored by the European University Institute. (Thanks to Klaus Graf.) According to the site, "Most of the listed websites can be accessed for free, though sometimes a registration is required."
Christian Zimmermann, RePEc in May 2009, The RePEc Blog, June 6, 2009
Have the Bermuda Principles kept up with the times?
David Dooling, Double standard, PolITiGenomics, June 5, 2009. (Thanks to Daniel MacArthur.)
The Bulletin of Mathematical Analysis and Applications is a new OA journal. The inaugural issue is now available. (Thanks to Marcus Zillman.)
New tool for finding full-text papers
Kevin Davies, Got PubMed? Pubget Searches and Delivers Scientific PDFs, Bio-IT World, June 10, 2009.
Report on PLoS' progress to date
Peter Jerram, Announcing the first PLoS Progress Report, Public Library of Science, June 8, 2009.
OA to 2 chapters of Heather Morrison book
Heather Morrison, Two OA chapters of Scholarly Communication for Librarians (in press), The Imaginary Journal of Poetic Economics, June 7, 2009.
The presentations from Deutscher Bibliothekartag (Erfurt, June 2-5, 2009) are now online. Several (for example, 1, 2, 3) are OA-related. Stuart Shieber, The argument for gold OA support, The Occasional Pamphlet, June 11, 2009. Excerpt:
Update (6/20/09). Also see Bill Hooker's comments on both Stevan Harnad's and Stuart Shieber's contributions in this debate. Creative repositories for the arts, EPrints News, June 2, 2009.
See also: Comment. I can't find the repository mentioned in the announcement. Is it the KULTUR Demonstrator? The project report points to repositories for UAL and UCA, but the links don't work.
You can now reach the ROARMAP list of funder and university OA policies with the shortcut URL, http://oamandates.org. (Thanks to Stevan Harnad.) Friend of OA and open govt joins the US National Archives Michael Sniffen, First Freedom of Information ombudsman appointed, Associated Press, June 10, 2009. Excerpt:
Comment. I got to know Miriam when she was legislative counsel for the ALA and an active and effective member of the Open Access Working Group. See for example her defense of the proposed OA mandate in the CURES Act of 2005. She's a superb choice to carry out the presumption in favor of disclosure that President Obama announced in his memo on the FOIA his first full day in office. (Congratulations, Miriam!) OA and the future of the monograph Sanford Thatcher, From the University Presses — The Hidden Digital Revolution in Scholarly Publishing: POD, SRDP, the “Long Tail,” and Open Access, Against the Grain, April 2009. Excerpt:
Coalition calls for OA in France
Three French associations have issued a call for a national policy on scientific and technical information. The associations are COUPERIN (Consortium Universitaire des Publications Numériques), ADBU (Association des directeurs et des personnels de direction des bibliothèques universitaires et de la documentation), and AURA (Association du réseau des établissements utilisateurs de l'ABES); see also comments by COUPERIN. The document calls for:
Interview on data sharing within GEOSS
The importance of data sharing within the Global Earth Observation System of Systems- CODATA speaks to José Achache, Director Geo Secretariat, CODATA Newsletter Special Issue, May 2009.
See also our past posts on GEOSS. Mandatory online access for publicly-funded research in Lithuania A new Lithuanian law on science requires online access for publicly-funded research. It was adopted by parliament on April 30 and took effect on May 12. Read the new law in Lithuanian or Google's English. Thanks to Emilija Banionyte and Rima Kupryte for hand-translating the section on research access:
Comments
Update (6/12/09). Emilija Banionyte tells me that in Lithuanian "to make public" suggests "free of charge" more often than not. However, the term doesn't always carry that implication and it's still too early to tell how lawyers and judges will interpret it. Labels: Hot Coalition of student organizations calls for OA SPARC, National student organizations call for Open Access to research, press release, June 10, 2009.
From the statement's call to action:
Disclosure. I have been a paid consultant for my work supporting this project. Labels: Hot Spread of OA in the field of art conservation Dan Cull, The Open Access Apocalypse, Dan Cull Weblog, June 10, 2009. Excerpt:
OA would save the Netherlands 133 million Euros/year John Houghton, Jos de Jonge, Marcia van Oploo, Costs and Benefits of Research Communication: The Dutch Situation, May 29, 2009. A major new report sponsored by the Dutch SURFfoundation. From the summary:
Also see today's press release:
Also see our past posts on Houghton's research on the economic impact of OA, including criticism from TA publishers and Houghton's responses. Labels: Hot Hoax exposes incompetence or worse at a Bentham OA journal Philip Davis, Open Access Publisher Accepts Nonsense Manuscript for Dollars, Scholarly Kitchen, June 10, 2009. Excerpt:
Also see Kent Anderson's follow-up post in the same blog:
Comments
Update. Also see Bob Grant's article in The Scientist. One new nugget:
Update. Klaus Graf calls for a boycott of Bentham. See his comments in German or Google's English. Update. Also see Paul Basken's article on the Chronicle of Higher Education News Blog. The comment section is starting to grow. Update. JURN, the search engine for OA journals in the arts and humanities, has stopped indexing Bentham journals. Update. Tom Wilson argues that the Bentham scandal is another reason to prefer no-fee OA journals. Update (6/11/09). Peter Aldhous in New Scientist reviews similar hoaxes in which journals or conferences were caught accepting outright nonsense. He also got an official response from Bentham:
Update (6/11/09). Also see Norman Oder's article in Library Journal. Update (6/11/09). The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA) points out several ways in which practices at Bentham Science appear to fall short of the association's code of conduct, and that Bentham is not a member of OASPA. Update (6/11/09). According to Bob Grant in The Scientist, the editor of the journal accepting the computer-generated nonsense paper, Bambang Parmanto, an information scientist at the U of Pittsburgh, has resigned. Update (6/13/09). Dorothea Salo wants universities with OA journal funds to refuse to pay publication fees charged by Bentham-like publishers, and wants librarians to help identify the Bentham-like publishers. Update (6/15/09). Kirsten at Into the Stacks wonders whether libraries should continue to support links to Bentham journals, and whether the DOAJ should continue to list them. Update (6/15/09). Also see Natasha Gilbert's article in Nature News. Bentham is standing by the story that it knew the paper was a hoax and pretended to accept it in order to learn the authors' true identities.
The April 2009 issue of Ariadne is now online. See especially:
OA to digitized journals in Gallica
Arnaud Dhermy, Les revues savantes dans Gallica, Gallica, June 5, 2009. Read it in the original French or Google's translation. Includes a table of journals digitized (or to be digitized) by region of France.
Momentum of OA means greater bargaining power for authors
Open Access Growing Steadily, But Powerful Gatekeepers Remain, CAUT Bulletin, June 2009.
An OA policy for the U of Bergen The University of Bergen has adopted an OA policy. (Thanks to Stevan Harnad.) From the ROARMAP version of the policy:
Comments
Labels: Hot Update to database of IRs in Japan
The IRDB Contents Analysis System, a database of Japanese IRs, was updated on June 2, 2009. (Thanks to Charles Bailey.)
Swedish Pirates win 1 seat in European Parliament Elections for European Parliament were held on June 4-7. One result is that Sweden's Pirate Party -- a supporter of OA -- gained its first seat. In Germany, the Pirate Party earned 0.9% of the vote: not enough for a seat in Parliament, but enough to qualify for public funding for future campaigns. For a broad overview of the election, see coverage in the New York Times. See also Klaus Graf's comments on why he voted for the Pirate Party (Google translation).
Digital Defoe is a new peer-reviewed OA journal of scholarship on Daniel Defoe. (Thanks to Wired Campus.) From the introduction:
... Unlike the pricey databases accessible only to those working in universities with big budgets, Digital Defoe is a publicly accessible, subscription-free peer-reviewed journal and online forum which all those working in higher and secondary education, as well as those outside of academia, are welcome to join. ... OA work of the Alliance for German Science Organizations Andreas Hübner and Christoph Bruch, Die Aktivitäten der Arbeitsgruppe „Open Access“ in der Schwerpunktinitiative Digitale Information der Allianz der deutschen Wissenschaftsorganisationen, a slide presentation at Deutscher Bibliothekartag (Erfurt, June 2-5, 2009). The abstract in Google's English:
Changing the default access rules is not unfair to publishers Stuart Shieber, Are the Harvard open-access policies unfair to publishers? The Occasional Pamphlet, June 9, 2009. Excerpt:
Peer review without assignment of copyright Leo Waaijers, Publish and Cherish with Non-proprietary Peer Review Systems, Ariadne, April 2009. Excerpt:
Comments
New issue of The Serials Librarian The latest issue of The Serials Librarian (vol. 56, nos. 1-4, 2009) is devoted to the presentations at NASIG 2008. Here are the OA-related items:
Digital humanities manifesto 2.0 The Mellon Seminar in Digital Humanities at UCLA released the Digital Humanities Manifesto 2.0. (Thanks to Charles Bailey.) Version 2.0 is just as vague on OA as version 1.0.
Open licenses to medical patents in developing countries Sean Flynn, Aidan Hollis, and Mike Palmedo, An Economic Justification for Open Access to Essential Medicine Patents in Developing Countries, The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, June 3, 2009. Accessible only to subscribers, at least so far.
More on OA to assist replication Scott M. Hofer, and Andrea M. Piccinin, Integrative data analysis through coordination of measurement and analysis protocol across independent longitudinal studies, Psychological Methods, June 2009. Accessible only to subscribers, at least so far.
OA journal introduces publication fees Paying for open access, Haematologica, June 2009. An editorial. Excerpt:
Randall Mayes, Openness and Biosecurity: Can They Co-exist? Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, June 7, 2009. Excerpt:
Comment. I already accept that patient privacy takes priority over OA. Hence I don't support OA to medical records without either anonymization or consent. In the right case I can accept that security also takes priority over OA. But I'm not sure this is the right case. A panel of the US National Research Council (NRC) considered exactly the case Mayes discusses --OA to genome data on pathogens-- and decided that the benefits outweighed the risks. In September 2004 it justified its assessment in a book-length report, which Mayes does not cite. (Also see my 2005 article on the NRC report.) I'm ready to believe that fabrication techniques have changed significantly since 2004, and that they will continue to lower the barriers to fabricating viruses from genomic blueprints. On the other hand, the NRC report rested on several arguments independent of the state of technology in 2004, for example, that suppressing factual knowledge about nature is ineffective, and that access to pathogen genome data is necessary to protect public health, especially in the face of bioterror. I'd like to see someone redo the NRC assessment in light of changing technology, or assess changing technology in light of the NRC's policy arguments. Another try at free to read, pay to print PaperC is a new platform for OA books. (Thanks to Blick Log.) At the moment Paper C is in beta and limited to invited users. According to Andreas Menn's article in Saturday's Handelsblatt (also see Google's English), reading a PaperC book online is free of charge, and users only have to pay if they want to print excerpts or annotate pages. PaperC is currently running a trial with 1,500 German students and 3,000 German books in computer science, economics, law, and medicine. Apparently the company will not publish its own books but merely host books from cooperating publishers. Olaf Ernst, President of E-Product Management & Innovation at Springer, said that PaperC was a promising model. Comment. This is essentially the business model of ebrary at the time of its launch, circa 2002. Sometime after 2005 ebrary changed its model, and now allows the original content publishers to choose their own business models. (None of the suggested models includes OA.) Does anyone know why ebrary changed? The reasons may affect the prospects of PaperC. OA databases for collaborative taxnomy Cene Fišer and three co-authors, Public online databases as a tool of collaborative taxonomy: a case study on subterranean amphipods, Zootaxa, May 2009. (Thanks to Layla Michán.) Accessible only to subscribers, at least so far.
Answering the fear about killing journals Stuart Shieber, The death of scholarly journals? The Occasional Pamphlet, June 8, 2009. Excerpt:
Comment. This is an excellent response that should circulate at all schools considering an OA policy. I'd only recommend that it reflect the fact, which Stuart recently confirmed, that most OA journals charge no publication fees. In the hypothetical world in which high-volume green OA puts pricing pressure on TA journals, many of those journals will convert to OA, but not all will convert to fee-based OA. There are many other business models for OA journals than charging publication fees. Likewise, in the hypothetical world in which high-volume green OA causes massive cancellations of TA journals, and libraries have correspondingly massive savings to spend on peer-reviewed OA journals, a new policy to pay publication fees will not help all or even most OA journals. The best no-fee journals will deserve support just as much as the best fee-based journals. Institutions thinking this far ahead should be thinking about how to help the no-fee journals as well, for example, through direct subsidies of cash, facilities, equipment, or personnel. More on Google Wave for open science Cameron Neylon, Google Wave In Research - The Slightly More Sober View - Part I - Papers, Science in the Open, June 8, 2009. Excerpt:
Update (6/8/09). Also see Part II, on using Google Wave for an open lab notebook.
Subbiah Arunachalam enters the blogosphere Subbiah Arunachalam (a.k.a. Arun) has launched a blog. Arun is India's leading OA activist and one of the leading activists for OA in developing countries worldwide. His blog is bound to become an important source of news and comment on OA in developing countries. On launch day --today-- Arun links back to some of his major interviews on OA. (Welcome, Arun!) Elsevier fake-journal tally now 9 Bob Grant, Elsevier tweaks custom pub rules, The Scientist, June 4, 2009. Excerpt:
Update. Also see Summer Johnson's comments at Bioethics.net. CLOCKSS preserves access to discontinued OUP title, an announcement from EDINA, May 31, 2009. Excerpt:
Also see the CLOCKSS archive of the BTCI backfile. All the back issues are hosted under a CC-BY-NC-ND license. eIFL's five years of OA advocacy in South Africa Gaining the momentum: eIFL marks five year commitment to Open Access in South Africa, eIFL.net. May 2009. Excerpt:
Ukraine is implementing its 2007 OA mandate Iryna Kuchma, Libraries advocating for open access in Ukraine, eIFL.net, May 2009. A report from an international conference in Sevastopol, Ukraine, May 21, 2009. Let me separate four bits of news so that none gets lost: (1) Ukraine is starting to implement the national OA mandate it adopted in 2007 but until now had not implemented:
(2) Ukrainian librarians issued a progressive statement endorsing OA:
(3) A Ukrainian research institute launched a new disciplinary repository:
(4) The Sevastopol conference proceedings are now online:
Presentations from South African OA meeting Presentations from the CSIR meeting, Gaining the momentum: Open access & advancement of science and research (Pretoria, May 14, 2009), are now online. Presentations from Palestinian OA workshop Presentations from the workshop, Open Access: Maximising Research Impact workshop in Palestine (Birzeit, May 25-28, 2009), are now online. |