Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Wednesday, December 03, 2008

How OA mandates can help society publishers

Dana L. Roth, FRPAA and NIH Mandate A Blessing in Disguise for Scientific Society Publishers? Science & Technology Libraries, September 15, 2008.  (Thanks to Charles Bailey.)  Only this abstract is OA at the journal site:

Abstract:   Society publishers are encouraged to view recent “Open Access” proposals as opportunities to expand access and balance subscription pricing with author contributions. This approach would hopefully avoid the difficulties inherent in the deposition and use of pre-publication manuscripts. Examples of reasonably priced society journals are presented along with comparison pricing of society and commercial journals. These examples suggest that society journals should be immune to cancellations, in contrast with the vulnerability of commercial journals.

But see the OA full-text, self-archived at Caltech.  From the conclusion:

Instead of following the example of the [American Chemical Society's] alignment with commercial publishers, as evidenced by recent revelations of questionable public-relation efforts, society publishers will hopefully see the FRPAA & NIH Directive as an opportunity to develop a new business model. Namely, one that includes appropriate 'open-access' for archival material, balanced pricing between authors and readers, and expanded outreach to underserved research communities, thus insuring the long-term survival of their publications.