Open Access NewsNews from the open access movement Jump to navigation |
|||
More on the international race to the bottom Michael Geist, Canadian Public Domain Told To Cease and Desist, Michael Geist's blog, October 21, 2007. Excerpt:
Comment. This is an important problem and the worst possible way to resolve it. Here's how I commented (October 2004) on a similar case in which the heirs of Margaret Mitchell demanded that Project Gutenberg of Australia take down a copy of Gone with the Wind which was in the public domain under Australian law but not under US law:
In my newsletter for 11/16/01, I looked at the possibility that IP-tracking software could solve this problem without all countries on Earth having to harmonize their copyright rules. But kudos to the Canadian Supreme Court for making that question moot and ruling (in effect) that the IMSLP needn't use IP-tracking software. Now it's time for Canada to protect conduct that is lawful in Canada. Update. Michael Hart of Project Gutenberg has offered a most welcome rescue. (Thanks to Glyn Moody.) Excerpt:
Update. Barbara Krasnoff has blogged a response from the German publisher, Universal Edition. In short: it only wanted IMSLP to remove the scores under German copyright and not to shut down the site. |