Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Monday, July 10, 2006

Blackwell Publishing Journal News

The July issue of Blackwell Publishing Journal News is now online. (Thanks to Donat Agosti.) There are four short articles on OA:
  1. Bob Campbell, Impact of Self-Archiving on Subscriptions
  2. Bob Campbell, The UK Research Councils Break Ranks
  3. Robert Harington, Where Next for the NIH’s Public Access Stance
  4. Ginny Foley, Funding and Bureaucracy, not Access to Journals, are Chief Obstacles to Scientific Productivity

Comment. To me, the most interesting of these is the second, on the RCUK. Campbell's spin is that the RCUK's draft OA policy emphasized the need for more study, and that the Medical Research Council has gone beyond the draft policy by mandating OA. The opposite is the case. The RCUK draft policy mandated OA across the board, for all eight of the Research Councils, even if it also recommended further study. The Medical Research Council is right in line with the draft, and the Research Councils not mandating OA, like the Council for the Central Laboratory of the Research Councils, are retreating from the draft. Don't take my word for it; read the draft yourself. Quoting Section 13: "RCUK believes that in order for Research Councils to demonstrate their commitment to enhancing access to published research outputs through the medium of e-print repositories, it should...introduce a requirement that Research Council-funded researchers should deposit their published outputs in appropriate e-print repositories." The details of the requirement are spelled out in Section 14.b.