Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Saturday, August 06, 2005

More on access v. security

Security Controls on Scientific Information and the Conduct of Scientific Research, a white paper from the Commission on Scientific Communication and National Security, Homeland Security Program, Center for Strategic and International Studies, June 2005. (Thanks to KnowledgeSpeak.) Excerpt:
If the results of that research are published openly, they become available to all—including to those who may seek to use those results maliciously. Therefore, policies to limit the ability of terrorists to access and exploit scientific research may gain approval which have the effect of constraining participation in, and dissemination of, that research. Such limitations do not come without cost. Open communication and participation are fundamental to the conduct of high-quality research, so constraints on that openness can have serious repercussions for the quality of that research, for the health of research and educational institutions, and ultimately for the societal objectives that research and education serve: national and homeland security, economic prosperity, health, environmental protection, and quality of life. Moreover, given the global nature of the scientific and technical enterprise, unilateral national policies to control scientific and technical information may have little prospect of effectively doing so. Information controls should not be imposed unless they can be shown to be effective and worth the penalties that they impose.