Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Monday, August 22, 2005

Defending the Medical R&D Treaty, inc. its provision on OA

Tim Hubbard, Reply to the comments requested by CIPIH and WHO to the CPTech proposal for a Medical Research and Development Treaty (MRDT), World Health Organization, August 22, 2005. Hubbard is the Head of Human Genome Analysis at the Sanger Institute. Excerpt:
[F.M.Scherer] suggested that sections of the treaty imply a direction away from granting exclusive licenses and imply that this could harm translation. However agencies with a mandate to improve public health, such as National Institutes of Health and Wellcome Trust, are already using a range of different approaches to ensure that research discoveries are developed into treatments, only one of which is exclusive licensing. Our view is that a mixed approach is likely to be the most successful, but that new open access approaches should be encourage where appropriate. Recent evidence suggests that the selective creation of public research resources (e.g. human genome sequence), which are of wide utility to other researchers, stimulate research activity more than any lose of potential exclusivity. More widely, encouraging researchers to be more proactive in sharing their data and research results, under open access research initiatives, also appears beneficial.

(PS: Disclosure: I helped draft the OA provision (§13.1) of the Medical R&D Treaty. For more details, see the CPTech page on the treaty.)