| Date | Opponent |
Site | Score |
| Tuesday, Sept. 1 |
at DePauw |
Greencastle, Indiana |
L, 6-15, 14-16, 7-15 |
| Saturday, Sept. 5 | at Oakland City | Oakland City, Indiana | L, 17-15, 10-15, 8-15, 13-15 |
| Saturday, Sept. 5 | Kentucky Wesleyan | Oakland City, Indiana | W, 12-15, 15-10, 15-8, 15-8 |
| Friday, Sept. 11 | Kalamazoo | Hanover, Indiana | L, 10-15, 12-15, 16-18 |
| Saturday, Sept. 12 | Ohio Wesleyan | Hanover, Indiana | L, 3-15, 5-15, 4-15 |
| Saturday, Sept. 12 | Franklin | Hanover, Indiana | L, 6-15, 6-15, 13-15 |
| Saturday, Sept. 12 | Olivet | Hanover, Indiana | W, 15-6, 15-10, 15-6 |
| Tuesday, Sept. 15 | OTTERBEIN | Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 12-15, 13-15, 15-9, 15-10, 6-15 |
| Thursday, Sept. 17 | ANDERSON | Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 9-15, 12-15, 8-15 |
| Friday, Sept. 18 | Bethany (W.Va.) | Westerville, Ohio | W, 15-10, 15-8, 9-15, 15-2 |
| Friday, Sept. 18 | Wilmington | Westerville, Ohio | W, 12-15, 15-3, 15-13, 15-4 |
| Saturday, Sept. 19 | at Otterbein | Westerville, Ohio | W, 15-9, 15-11, 15-8 |
| Saturday, Sept. 19 | Capital | Westerville, Ohio | L, 8-15, 10-15, 13-15 |
| Saturday, Sept. 19 | Marietta | Westerville, Ohio | L, 15-8, 6-15, 7-15, 12-15 |
| Tuesday, Sept. 22 | *WITTENBERG | Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 7-15, 8-15, 14-16 |
| Tuesday, Sept. 29 | at Wilmington | Wilmington, Ohio | W, 15-11, 15-9, 15-11 |
| Saturday, Oct. 3 |
FRANKLIN |
Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 11-15, 12-15, 12-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 3 |
SAINT FRANCIS |
Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 10-15, 4-15, 2-15 |
| Thursday, Oct. 8 | INDIANA WESLEYAN | Trueblood Fieldhouse | L, 8-15, 19-21, 8-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 10 | *Allegheny | Granville, Ohio | L, 7-15, 14-16, 7-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 10 | *at Denison | Granville, Ohio | L, 7-15, 2-15, 5-15 |
| Tuesday, Oct. 13 | WILMINGTON | Trueblood Fieldhouse | W, 15-6, 15-9, 14-16, 15-4 |
| Saturday, Oct. 17 | *at Kenyon | Gambier, Ohio | L, 15-10, 10-15, 9-15, 11-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 17 | *Oberlin | Gambier, Ohio | W, 10-15, 15-10, 15-5, 15-8 |
| Tuesday, Oct. 20 | *at Ohio Wesleyan | Delaware, Ohio | L, 7-15, 12-15, 11-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 24 | *at Case Western Reserve | Cleveland, Ohio | L, 6-15, 16-18, 13-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 24 | *Wooster | Cleveland, Ohio | L, 11-15, 16-14, 2-15, 7-15 |
| Tuesday, Oct. 27 | ROSE-HULMAN | Trueblood Fieldhouse | W, 9-15, 15-6, 16-14, 12-15, 15-13 |
| Saturday, Oct. 31 | Goshen | Anderson, Indiana | W, 15-11, 14-16, 15-3, 6-15, 16-14 |
| Saturday, Oct. 31 | at Anderson | Anderson, Indiana | L, 6-15, 1-15, 12-15 |
| Saturday, Oct. 31 | Urbana | Anderson, Indiana | W, 11-15, 15-6, 15-13, 15-8 |
| Tuesday, Nov. 3 | at Wittenberg (NCAC Quarterfinal) | Springfield, Ohio | L, 0-15, 4-15, 2-15 |